Couldn't have been better! I took my two daughters, 5 and 6, and we all had a blast. Lots of smaller fish for the kids to bring in by themselves, big ones for dad including a 100lb shark, and plenty to take home for a great dinner. If you're chartering in Amelia island, don't bother with anyone else!
Edit: A few months on, and my daughter (6) still asks when we will see captain Billy again. I cant express how gracious, accommodating and friendly the crew was to me and my children. When we fish at home she now tells me "Billy would find the real big fish."